SIREN CALL

[Jefferaldo]

Mmm I noticed that I have not seen this writer before. Julie Martin - her first time writing for CI.

[cifan]

I finally got around to voting. I really enjoyed this episode and gave it an A. It would have been an A+ if it wasn't for the sexualized violence. I thought the storyline was great, but they could have toned down Ashley's appearance and behavior

Also, it would have had the same impact, imo, if we would have heard the gunshot and seen the stepdad laying on the ground. I didn't need to see him blow his brains out. That wasn't CI.

Unlike many posters, I'm fine with the direction they're taking the characters personally. I'm not seeing soap..yet.

[NicoleMarie]

I only seen 20 minutes of this one but wanted to give it an F just based on those 20 minutes. I'll wait until it reairs Saturday night before I do vote.

Wow, those last 20 minutes were misleading. No F, I vote C.

[ladyday]

B- instead of a C because of the tension with Goren. Some of the story didn't make sense to me.

[Techguy]

Bump for EOTW voting

For the record, I'm one of those who cast an F vote.

[DonnaJo]

For some reason I've never voted for this episode before. A belated high five to Trisha for her great poll quotes, especially the Simpson one. ;D

I gave it a C for an overall rating. If the rating could be broken up, the very beginning (sexually exploitive) and ending (Goren sans heroics and VDO over angst-ing) would be an F. But in the middle there were some really good A scenes, like when they apprehend the Dad and Bobby breaks the glass. Also when Goren and Eames arrest the lover, and he takes a swing at Bobby after hitting on Eames. Good stuff.